Where to Keep Short-Terms Savings

With interest rates at historic lows, savings accounts just aren’t paying the kind of interest they used to. Many big banks are paying between 0.01% and 0.10%, which is essentially nothing. Online bank interest rates are currently ranging from about 0.5% to 1%, which is certainly more but still nothing to get too excited about. In both cases, your money is losing some purchasing power due to inflation.

With rates so low, many people are wondering what they should do with their short-term savings. If they’re currently with a big bank, should they move to an online bank for a better rate? If they’re currently earning 0.8%, should they switch to an account that earns 1%? What about putting some money into slightly riskier investments, such as bonds or even stocks, in the hopes of a higher return?

My advice? For short-term savings, the interest rate should be one of your last concerns. It’s much more important to focus on your contribution rate and the convenience of the account for your savings purposes. Let me talk about some of these factors one at a time.

What are short-term savings?

First, what do I mean by short-term savings? Any money that you might need in the next 1-2 years should be considered short-term. This would include your emergency fund. It includes any “saving to spend” funds. It should also include any other savings goal where you can’t afford for the actual dollar amount of the account to drop.

Where to keep this money

There are three main factors to consider when choosing a bank for your savings:
1. How easy it is to transfer money into the account?
2. How easy is it to access the money in a relatively short time period without penalty?
3. Are there any restrictions, minimums or limitations on the account that will cause problems?

The first factor is pretty simple. It should be very convenient for you to send money to this account, preferably with automated monthly transfers from your checking account. Most banks will allow you to do this, but make sure that you understand the process and that it will be easy for you.

You should also be able to access the money relatively easily, though you might want to consider using an account where the access isn’t too easy. For example, withdrawals from most online savings banks will take about 3 business days to reach your checking account. This is quick enough that it gives you good access, but not so fast that you’re tempted to use your savings for impulse spending. In any case, you should make sure that there aren’t penalties assessed for regular transactions. Penalties can often wipe out any interest the account has earned.

Finally, understand any other restrictions, minimum account balances and other limitations that might be on the account. If any of these seem like they will cause a problem, look at other bank. There are enough options that you should be able to find one you’re comfortable with.

Does it fit your savings strategy?

You want to choose a bank that will allow you to save in a manner that fits your overall strategy. For me, I like being able to segregate my savings my goal. Some people can manage this with a single account and simply track their savings goals in excel. I prefer to have this accomplished with either different accounts, or with a single account where the bank lets you segregate different purposes. One of the reasons we chose Ally Bank for our short-term savings is that it’s really simple to add multiple savings accounts, name them for our different goals, but essentially manage them as one account. I’ve also heard from a lot of people who use ING for this same purpose.

This particular purpose may not be an important factor for you. But the point is that you should know how you want to use your account and make sure that the bank you choose will allow it.

How to grow these accounts

The biggest factor in growing the balances on these accounts is not the interest rate. It’s your contribution rate. Remember, these are short-term savings, so no matter what rate you’re earning they won’t have a lot of time to compound and grow. It’s much more important to focus on how much and how often you are contributing. If you can contribute $100 per month, you’ll have added $1,200 in value over a year. In that same period, you would earn about $6 in interest with a 0.1% rate and about $68 in interest with a 1% rate. There is definitely a difference in interest there, but it pales in comparison to what you can add just by contributing more. A focus first and foremost on your contribution rate will go much further towards building your savings.

With that said, it does make sense to focus on interest rates to some extent. If you find several options that fit all of the previously mentioned factors, then choosing one with a more competitive rate makes some sense. I would look for a bank that has consistently offered a competitive rate. It’s less important that it’s the best right now than that you can feel confident that it will be near the best going forward. It’s consistent good service that you’re looking for, not a short-term highest offer.

Be in it for the long term

Whatever option you choose, you should feel comfortable with that being your banking option for the long-term. It doesn’t mean that you’re committing forever, or that you couldn’t change your mind, but you should go into it with the realistic hope that it’s a relationship you can keep. You don’t want to get into the interest-rate chasing game, and you don’t want to have to re-do all this work in another 6-12 months. Finding a bank that you feel like you can work with for years will allow you to set up your system and move on with as little further stress as possible.

Start building a better financial future with the resource I wish I had when I was starting my family. It’s free!

2 Comments... Read them below or add one of your own
  • WILLIAM CHESTER December 2, 2017

    Hi Matt,

    I know this post was a while ago, but when I’m reading your other posts, and select other links that takes me to more great content, I wind up here. So, in regards to Ally in the paragraph ‘Does it fit your savings strategy’ where you said you like using Ally for multiple savings accounts, but manage them as one account. I’d like to know if Ally shows as one account in Mint or if it would still separate out all of those accounts in the Overview, like my Bank accounts. It would be great if the total value, for all savings accounts in Ally, were listed as one. Just wondering if you know.

    Also, it would be great if all of your posts were organized out by year or content they included, categories/strategies. By selecting Blog at the top I was able to look at prior posts, but I was searching back through time, where I really wanted to find this post that was more relevant to a later dated post.

    Great work though, I really enjoy reading/learning new thoughts/concepts.


    • Matt Becker December 4, 2017

      Good question William. Multiple Ally accounts display as multiple accounts in tools like Mint. Recently though I’ve started using You Need a Budget, which kind of goes the other way in terms of letting you split a single savings account into multiple categories, allowing you to consolidate your real accounts and track separate savings goals in the app instead. It’s really simplified things for me.

      Also, I appreciate your suggestion about organizing my content and I actually 100% agree. I have plans to move away from the “blog” page to more of a “resources” page organized by topic in order to make things easier for people to find. Hopefully that will be happening in the near future.

Leave a Comment